Every week I speak with attorneys who have trouble reconciling the conflicts in the relationships they have with clients: Creditor and Advocate. They call me on the telephone and they invite me into their offices for on-site consultations. They tell me of their troubles and ask me for help. I am a Practice Management Advisor with How To Make It Rain.com and these are my stories:
I visited "John" in his Orlando, Florida office. He called me to ask for help. He was working harder than ever but never seemed to take home enough money. He thought his expenses were too high. John was even considering letting a secretary go whom he was sure, was taking office supplies home for her kids. (Office supplies typically represent less than 1% of a law firm’s annual budget.)
ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE: Clients pay us to solve their problems, we are not supposed to pay for them!
Once John understood the importance of screening Prospective New Clients in a systematic and professional manner to weed out the potentially bad ones, he was ready to think about business. The first thing we had to address was the ridiculous level of old & dusty accounts receivable that were indirectly costing him money each month.
One of the reasons for John’s unhappy condition were his conflicting feelings. These feelings were never discussed in his professional responsibility course during law school. Instead, John learned the hard way how really difficult it is to serve someone as both their creditor and their advocate. These two roles have inherent conflicts.
John eventually decided to require all of his clients to make a lump-sum deposit to his trust account to cover the entire cost of his services, up-front. He discovered that more clients than he had expected, actually had the money to do this & for the others he now offers them the option to pay by credit card. Now John can fight like crazy to advance his clients’ interests and protect their rights and he let’s Visa or Master Card worry about being their creditor.
Not only does this arrangement remove the inherent conflict, allow John to do a better job for his clients and eliminate costly accounts receivable problems, it even makes the client’s life a little easier.
Attorney Tracy Griffin, President of Attorney Card Services (727) 341-2323 ([email protected]) observes: "Contrary to what many attorneys think, clients who have not paid their bill do feel uncomfortable communicating with their attorney/creditor. It’s no fun for either the attorney or the client to talk about a case or matter when they both know about, and are trying to politely avoid the subject of past due bills."
Accepting Credit Cards Will Make Your Firm More Profitable
When John decided to get serious about wanting to be a more profitable, ethical and professional lawyer he made the decision to focus first on properly managing his law firm. John realized that despite what he had been hearing and repeating to others for years, it really is possible to budget a case or matter ahead of time with an adequate degree of accuracy in all but the most complex contentious cases. Better yet, John realized that if he over-budgeted he could always impress the client when he returned some of their unused money.
Case-budgetiung puts John much further ahead of the game than when he used to ask for retainer deposits at random. Best of all though, by investing the time to budget a case in the beginning, John now finds that he is able to be more pro-active in case or matter management and he has virtually eliminated the worst part of being a lawyer: Collections.
In the beginning it was a little scary for him, but today, John recognizes that requiring clients to make a large lump-sum deposit into his trust account to cover all anticipated fees and costs has the effect of dramatically increasing firm income for three main reasons:
1. There is less tendency to write-down the bill when you already have the money sitting in your trust account.
2. There is less tendency for the client to negotiate down the bill after it’s already been paid.
3. Collections are far more timely, i.e. reduced (or eliminated) accounts receivable. This improves firm cash flow and actually reduces firm overhead.
Think about it: You have your own credit card bills, car loan, line of credit or home mortgage all of which are charging you every day for the use of their money. If your client owes you $1,000 for three months, you are in effect borrowing money from your own highest interest rate creditor in order to be able to afford to loan that money to your client at no interest!
In the past, John would do the work and send a bill to the client at the conclusion of the representation. After three months, he would often end up writing the bill down 10% from $7,500 to only $6,750 just to get some money flowing in. After three months, the $6,750 really ended up benefiting John the equivalent of only $6,402 after the discount and interest expense. $7,500 vs. $6,402 = $1,098 or 15% reduced revenue. If John let this happen in only half of his cases each year and he regularly collected 1,500 hours per year, John could have taken a entire month off of work and still had the same income had he simply gained control of his A/R.